top of page

Shame in adoptive parenting: the feeling nobody names at the panel

11 minutes ago
3 min read

You lost your temper. You did the thing you swore you would not do. Your child looks at you in a way that confirms the worst thing you believe about yourself. You wait until they are asleep and then sit on the kitchen floor and cry.


This is shame. In adoptive parenting it is one of the most common and least talked about experiences of the whole process.


Shame is not the same as guilt


Guilt is a feeling about what you did. Shame is a feeling about who you are. The research of Brené Brown has made this distinction widely recognisable, and it matters enormously in adoptive parenting. Guilt about losing your temper is uncomfortable but useful. It prompts repair. Shame about being a bad parent is corrosive and tends to spiral.


Adoptive parents often experience both at once, with shame doing most of the damage. The guilt leads to apology and reconnection. The shame leads to isolation, perfectionism, and the quiet conviction that you are not up to the job.


Why shame lands particularly hard in adoption


A few things stack up in adoption that intensify shame.


You chose this. The assumption that you knew what you were signing up for sits behind many of the harder moments. Expressing difficulty can feel like admitting you made a mistake, which can quickly become shame about having become a parent in this way.


You were approved by a system. Adopters have been assessed, interviewed, and formally judged suitable. When things go badly, the implicit comparison with that approval is sharp. If I was approved, I should be able to manage this.


You often cannot talk about it. The sensitive and sometimes confidential nature of your child's history means many of the specifics cannot be shared with friends who might otherwise offer support. The shame has nowhere to go.


Your child's response to you can confirm the worst thing you believe. A child who recoils from your repair, who stays angry long after you have apologised, who looks at you with suspicion for days, inadvertently feeds the shame story. Their behaviour is almost always about something older than you, but it is received by your nervous system as evidence against yourself.


A moody black and white portrait of a woman sitting alone, representing the shame many adoptive parents feel but rarely speak about

What the research says about shame and parenting


Shame in parents is strongly associated with what Daniel Hughes and Jonathan Baylin call blocked care, a state in which the parts of the brain that generate warm, attuned parenting go briefly offline under sustained stress. Shame is both a cause and a consequence of blocked care, which is one reason the loop is so hard to break alone.


Adoption UK's Barometer surveys have consistently found that adoptive parents report higher rates of parental mental health difficulties than the general population, with shame and isolation among the most reported experiences.


What helps with shame


The research on shame points in one direction. It survives in silence and dies in connection. Telling someone, even one person, almost always reduces the grip of it.


Peer support with other adoptive parents is often the most reliable antidote. Adopters who understand the specific texture of this work tend to receive shame with less flinching than friends who have not been there, and the recognition itself does much of the work.


The Adoption UK community and PAC-UK's family support services both offer peer and therapeutic routes in. If the shame is persistent or linked to depression, your GP is a reasonable starting point for additional support.


Therapeutic approaches that specifically address shame, including compassion-focused therapy and some trauma-focused work, can be particularly useful when the shame is older than this specific parenting moment and connects to earlier experiences in your own life.


What changes when shame is named


Adopters who find a safe place to put the shame, a trusted friend, a therapist, a peer group, consistently describe the same shift. The reactions in parenting get smaller. The repair with their child becomes easier. The quiet conviction of being bad at this slowly loosens.


The shame is not evidence that you should not be doing this. It is evidence that the work is harder than people realise, and that you are a human being doing it rather than a service provider. Naming it is one of the single most protective things you can do for both yourself and your child.





Thanks for reading,


The Walk Together team

Comments


bottom of page